Influence Line Tutorial for HA UDL and HB Loading Bending Effects

Example: Three span deck with continuity over pier supports.


 *
 
 

Step1: Determine the position of the point of maximum bending moment in each element for a single point load.

*

Point A − maximum sagging moment in span 1
Point B − maximum hogging moment over pier 1
Point C − maximum sagging moment in span 2
Note: as end spans are equal then critical points over pier 2 and in span 3 can be obtained from point A and B by symmetry.
 
 

Step 2: Determine influence line diagram for point A:

*
 
 

Step 3: Determine influence line diagram for point B:

*
 
 

Step 4: Determine influence line diagram for point C:

*
 
 

Step 5: Determine loading for critical cases:

Point A
The maximum sagging moment is achieved by loading spans 1 and 3, however we also need to check HA UDL for loading in span 1 only.
 

HA Span 1 only: loaded length = 10m hence udl = 71.8 kN/m (BD37-table 13)
HA Span 1 and 3: loaded length = 20m hence udl = 45.1 kN/m (BD37-table 13)
KEL: = 120 kN (BD37- Clause 6.2.2)
 

HB loading will produce worst sagging moment with an axle at the maximum ordinate (2.15). Any one of the 4 axles can be located at this position; the vehicle is however positioned with the other 3 axles to achieve the maximum total ordinates:

 

*
 
 

Note: The HB vehicle has a range of spacings between the centre axles, in this case the 26m spacing gives the worst effect. 
 

Point B
The maximum hogging moment is achieved by loading spans 1 and 2, however we also need to check HA UDL for loading in span 2 only.
 

HA Span 2 only: loaded length = 20m hence udl = 45.1 kN/m (BD37-table 13)
HA Span 1 and 2: loaded length = 30m hence udl = 34.4 kN/m (BD37-table 13)
KEL: = 120 kN (BD37- Clause 6.2.2)
 

Usually HB loading will produce the worst hogging moment with an axle at the maximum ordinate (2.051). Any one of the 4 axles can be located at this position; the vehicle is however positioned with the other 3 axles to achieve the maximum total ordinates.
In the case below the sum of the ordinates is 0.677 + 0.71 + 2.051 + 1.966 = 5.404

*
 
 

Other cofigurations of HB loading need be checked, and in this case the 6m vehicle will produce a greater value with the vehicle in the position shown below. The sum of the ordinates for this configuration = 1.604 + 1.943 + 1.651 + 1.305 = 6.503

*
 
 

 
 

Point C
The maximum sagging moment is achieved by loading span 2 only.
 

HA Span 2 only: loaded length = 20m hence udl = 45.1 kN/m (BD37-table 13)
KEL: = 120 kN (BD37- Clause 6.2.2)
 

HB loading will produce worst sagging moment with an axle at the maximum ordinate (3.125). Any one of the 4 axles can be located at this position; the vehicle is however positioned with the other 3 axles to achieve the maximum total ordinates:

 

*
 
 

Note: The HB vehicle has a range of spacings between the centre axles, in this case the 6m spacing gives the worst effect.  
 

Step 6: Determine load effects on deck.

The following assumptions will be made to demonstrate principles of influence lines:
 • Assume loads applied to 1 notional lane width of deck (3.65m wide).
 • Assume ultimate limit state hence use load factor γfL of 1.5 for HA loading and 1.3 for HB loading.
 • Assume 30 units of HB.

Span 1
Maximum sagging moment due to HB loading:
M = 1.3 x 30 x 10 x (2.172 + 1.345 + 0.088 + 0.108) = 1448 kNm
 
Maximum sagging moment due to HA loading at point A:
Case 1 − Span1 loaded
M = 1.5 x (71.8 x 10.285 + 120 x 2.172) = 1499 kNm (HA critical)
Case 2 − Span1 and 3 loaded
M = 1.5 x [45.1 x (10.285 + 0.695) + 120 x 2.172] = 1134 kNm
 

Pier 1
Maximum hogging moment due to HA loading at point B:
Case 1 − Span 2 loaded
M = 1.5 x (45.1 x 24.776 +120 x 2.051) = 2045 kNm
Case 2 − Span1 and 2 loaded
M = 1.5 x [34.4 x (24.776 + 4.641) + 120 x 2.051] = 1887 kNm
 
Maximum hogging moment due to HB loading:
M = 1.3 x 30 x 10 x (1.604 + 1.943 + 1.651 + 1.305) = 2536 kNm (HB critical)
 

Span 2
Maximum sagging moment due to HA loading at point C:
Case 1 − Span 2 loaded
M = 1.5 x (45.1 x 25.25 + 120 x 3.125) = 2271 kNm
 
Maximum sagging moment due to HB loading:
M = 1.3 x 30 x 10 x (3.125 + 2.286 + 0.8 + 0.366) = 2565 kNm (HB critical)
 

Note: HB loading is shown to be critical for two of the cases, however if the loads are distributed using a computer analysis, such as a grillage analysis, then the HB moments will be reduced considerably.
 
 

A spreadsheet (InfLine.zip) is availble to download which will provide the influence line diagram, areas and ordinates required to determine critical moments as detailed above.
 

Back to Tutorials Index

For more information :

Contact David Childs